Ok, here is my view of The top 11 from American Idol, there are two to three things following each name, the first is an indication of what I think of their performance, the second is what I think when they aren’t performing and the third is only there if I don’t mind if they leave… So if they don’t have a third thing I would be very sad if they were sent home. So here is my top 11…
Mandisa 
Bucky 
*
Paris *
Chris
Katherine
Taylor
Lisa :-l :-l *
Kevin :-l *
Elliot :-l *
Kellie
Ace